Have you noticed that it is hard to find a good eyebrow pencil? Many have the wrong choice of colors, they are too soft and smudgy, plus fade way too fast… Let me comfort you, though. The best brow pencil does exist! I’ve found my perfect brow product, and I hope my roundup will help you pick your favorite that will prove a truly professional eyebrow pencil which is just right!
What Makes the Best Eyebrow Pencil?
Well, the best brow pencil is the one that fulfills all of your expectations, that is it creates the best makeup looks, stays put the longest possible, has nice shades, and is easy to use plus affordable of course. It is great if it also lasts us long; I had many brow pencils that would break during application and the ones that didn’t last long. Another thing that makes a good eyebrow pencil is the resistance to rain but note that it doesn’t need to be waterproof to be long-wear. I’m more into non-waterproof brow pencils which are easier to take off and don’t need rubbing (and causing damage to brow hair).
How Did I Rank the Brow Pencils?
I decided to do it the right way and create a professional ranking of the best brow pencils. I tested each of the purchased products in various weather conditions for a week, checking the colors, how long they stay put, and the price of course. I did it all to make sure it’s a reliable review that points to the unquestioned winner, the best eyebrow pencil out there.
RANKING of TOP Eyebrow Pencils
#1 NANOBROW EYEBROW PENCIL
Here’s a precision brow pencil with a spoolie. The product topped the competitive brands and stole my heart! <3 The things that make it special are the ultra-fine tip, the best pigments, and optimal texture, neither too soft nor too hard. It is just right for creating flawless brow makeup! Nanobrow pencil is super precise, fine-tipped, and easy to work with. I use it for drawing super-thin lines and filling the brows with color. I like the brush which is great for combing through brows and putting them in the desired position. I’m in love with this brow product! This is my best brow pencil ever. At the same time, it’s great value for money, and stays on brows all day. No smudging, no clumping, no color fading. The Nanobrow Eyebrow Pencil is my number one and I’m not gonna buy other brow fillers for sure.
Brow Pencil Reviews
The Nanobrow Eyebrow Pencil received rave reviews. I couldn’t find a single negative review, to be honest. I’m not surprised it’s such a popular brow pencil because it really is top quality. And I love the price! <3
#2 ANASTASIA BEVERLY HILLS BROW WIZ
The wax brow pencil with a spoolie from ABH is probably one of the world’s most famous brow fillers, which is for the brand’s popularity of course. The retractable brow pencil has a nice texture, works well for filling in the brows, hiding the gaps. It’s a vegan brow pencil, quite long-wear and resistant to rubbing off. It isn’t a waterproof eyebrow pencil but it does stay put all day. You can pick out one of the 12 available shades.
Formulated without microplastic, parabens and allergens. It is a good brow pencil yet not the best one! The thing that keeps it from reaching top of the ranking is the high price and the shades that are mostly warm and orangish.
Brow Pencil Reviews
The ABH brow pencil gets very positive reviews. It’s mostly appreciated by makeup artists and is a professional product for brow makeup.
#3 BENEFIT PRECISELY MY BROW PENCIL
This waterproof brow pencil also has a built-in spoolie brush. I do like it, however, I think it isn’t good value for money. I’m glad there are other brow fillers delivering top quality for a great price, otherwise, I would be broke 🙂 The brow pencil from BENEFIT comes in many shades so you’ll be spoilt for choice. I think you’ll choose the most suitable shade for your skin tone easily. This brow product provides extreme coverage so it makes a great choice for evening makeup looks. It’s hard to remove though. Rubbing the brows is needed.
Eyebrow Pencil Reviews
As you all probably guess, this brow pencil is rated highly and appreciated by makeup artists for nice makeup looks and the wide range of shades. A pro can pick the right one for a client effortlessly.
#4 FENTY BEAUTY BROW MVP ULTRA FINE BROW PENCIL & STYLER
A waterproof brow pencil with a brush applicator yet the brush is rather unusual… It isn’t a spoolie or comb, it’s a flat brush. What’s it like to use it? That depends on your preferences. I like the pencil but I don’t like this brush because it deposits too much product, smudging the skin. Still, that’s up to you, whatever floats your boat. When it comes to available shades I was overwhelmed; there are as many as 14 shades, which is why I had problems with picking the best one. I guess it’s easier for a qualified makeup artist. At the same time, it’s pricey and I’m not sure if it’s worth the money.
Brow Pencil Reviews
Rihanna’s products are extremely popular, which is why the brow pencil enjoys great popularity too. Is it the best brow filler, though? A matter of taste. I don’t think it deserves the podium.
#5 KVD BEAUTY SIGNATURE BROW
A precise eyebrow pencil with a spoolie, high priced yet not overpriced like some products in my roundup. I really like the shades and makeup looks it creates, but I wish it stayed put longer… It didn’t last all day, got slightly smudged, and my brows didn’t look polished as they did in the morning… I hoped for better results with Kat Von D…
Brow Pencil Reviews
I know there’s a big gang of Kat Von D’s fans and I’m not surprised. I also use many products from the brand like the brilliant foundations. However, I’m not into this brow pencil. I’m not saying it’s useless. I just know there are much better brow fillers at better prices and shades.
How Much Is a Brow Pencil?
I’m sure you’re wondering what price you need to pay for a good brow pencil that fulfills its tasks and works smoothly. Obviously, quality brow products don’t need to be pricey. Saying that the most expensive cosmetics are the best ones is just a myth. These days, good quality is offered at attractive prices, which is why I hope my ranking of the best brow pencils will help you pick your favorite and you won’t need to search among those with offputting prices.
Eyebrow Pencil. Where to Buy It?
You often ask me where to buy the best brow pencil and I’m sure many of you start shopping by googling eyebrow pencil sephora, eyebrow pencil amazon, etc. Many brow pencils are available at large cosmetics stores. You can buy these online or in store but I suggest comparing offers because the prices vary for the same product depending on the store. Go and hunt for special deals. I like to buy directly from cosmetic brands, and recommend checking Nanobrow’s website where you can get more brilliant brow products, not only the brow pencil I love. Nanobrow are experts for flawless brows!
How to Use a Brow Pencil for the Best Results?
If you start applying brow makeup by drawing hair-like strokes, in a messy way, then I need to warn you against doing that. First, you need to outline the brows and make them shapely. Ideally, do it using a brow pencil and keep the brows symmetric. Then, you can move on to filling the brows. Just remember to put more product on the brow end, aka tail, and keep the start of the brow lighter.
What are your thoughts now? Is the ranking useful? Have you picked your favorite brow pencil yet? Hope so! <3
